I'm Leaving It All Up To You will stay in your cart for 60 minutes to give you more time to shop. After 60 minutes, if someone else wants your album, you may lose it.
Showing 1–50 of 1353 results (new arrivals at top).
700 New Arrivals 10 AM CST Fridays + 100 7pm CST Wednesdays
Buyer Reviews
“I received my albums today and even though the records are used they are in great condition. All were VG++ to mint. I will be ordering again.”
Hank Edwards
Oak Hill, West Virginia
“Everything came in great shape and played perfectly. Shipping was quick. Can’t wait to order again.”
Bob Stedeford
Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania
“First purchase and it went very well. Good communication and timely shipping as described. I’ve already found myself looking for more.”
Lee Fortier
“I received my first order (6 records) yesterday and was kind of nervous about their actual condition until I opened them and played them. I can honestly say I am very pleased. They all played perfectly. All of the records themselves are pretty much NM (near mint) and the record sleeves are in really good condition with the usual wear but nothing major or horrible. I received one that was still sealed, which I always think is cool to come across with older records. I will definitely be ordering again soon.”
Ari Scott Faithfull
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Not too long ago I tried 5DollarRecords. I highly recommend 5DollarRecords to anyone who enjoys vinyl.”
Tom Thomas
“Really good product and really good service! Everything I have ordered has been in excellent shape. Customer service is really good too!”
Erik Linderholm
Illinois
“Awesome website. Always has something I love. Highly recommend.”
Suzanne Lesley
“Great selection of albums, all genres. Always in great condition & the covers too.”
Carl Howe
“Awesome website and the albums I’ve received have all been in great condition.”
Michael Noe
Barberton, Ohio
“Awesome shipping speed all the albums were in great condition and at a great price. I will be shopping with you again. Thanks!”
Wes Love
Elizabethton, Tennessee
“One of the best websites around! I’ve ordered from them many times and they are always so responsive and fast shipping!”
Layne Lewis
Overland Park, Kansas
“I’ve bought over two dozen records from $5 Records. Excellent records great pricing and super fast shipping.”
Ed Bouwsma
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Shopping Cart